Best Roofers in Lake Monticello, VA
20 verified roofers serving Lake Monticello. Compare ratings, read reviews, and get free estimates.
Ranked Pros
20
scored & compared
Average Cost
$4650–$13950
full replacement
Top Score
53/100
HomeProx rating
Service Area
Lake Monticello
Fluvanna County
How we rank roofers
Every business gets a HomeProx Score (0-100) based on multiple trust signals. Here is how the score breaks down:
30
Google Rating
20
Review Volume
15
VA License
15
Yelp Rating
Additional points for BBB accreditation (10), free estimates (5), and web presence (5). Rankings are updated hourly.
Hiring a roofer in Lake Monticello
We tracked 20 roofers working in Lake Monticello, VA and scored each one on the signals that actually matter when a contractor is walking into your home: Google and Yelp reviews at scale, verified Virginia DPOR licensing, BBB standing, and whether they publish pricing or offer free estimates. Typical roofer pricing in the Fluvanna County area runs $4650–$13950 full replacement, though the ends of that range reflect very different jobs.
If you're hiring for roofing work in Lake Monticello, focus on three things: check the license at dpor.virginia.gov, get at least three written estimates (pricing spreads are wider than homeowners expect), and read the 1-star reviews — they tell you more about the operation than the 5-stars do. Below is the ranked list; each profile has the review themes, pricing range, and credential check for that specific business.
20 Roofers, ranked
Why #1: 4.8-star Google rating from 425 reviews.
Why #2: 4.9-star Google rating from 198 reviews.
Why #3: 5.0-star Google rating from 102 reviews.
Why #4: 5.0-star Google rating from 82 reviews.
Why #5: 4.8-star Google rating from 86 reviews.
Why #6: 4.9-star Google rating (31 reviews).
Why #7: 5.0-star Google rating (25 reviews).
Why #8: 5.0-star Google rating (20 reviews).
Why #9: 4.8-star Google rating (20 reviews).
Why #10: 5.0-star Google rating (14 reviews).
Why #11: 4.7-star Google rating (20 reviews).
Why #12: 5.0-star Google rating (11 reviews).
Why #13: 5.0-star Google rating (16 reviews).
Why #14: 4.1-star Google rating (32 reviews).
Why #15: 4.8-star Google rating (19 reviews).
Why #16: 5.0-star Google rating (6 reviews).
Why #17: 5.0-star Google rating (6 reviews).
Why #18: 4.6-star Google rating (9 reviews).
Why #19: 4.8-star Google rating (8 reviews).
Why #20: 5.0-star Google rating (4 reviews).
Related Services
How to Hire a Roofer in Lake Monticello
Finding a reliable roofer in Lake Monticello, VA starts with understanding what drives costs and quality in the Fluvanna County area. We've compiled 20 verified professionals to help you compare.
Key Cost Factors
- Roof size (square footage): Roofers price by the 'square' (100 sq ft). Most Charlottesville-area homes are 15-25 squares, with each square costing $350-$500 for asphalt shingles installed.
- Material type: Architectural shingles run $350-$500 per square installed, while standing-seam metal costs $800-$1,200 per square. Metal is increasingly popular in the Blue Ridge foothills for its 50-year lifespan and wind resistance.
- Pitch/slope: Roofs steeper than 6:12 pitch require harnesses and specialized staging, adding 15-25% to labor costs. Many older homes in Charlottesville's historic districts have steep Victorian-era pitches.
- Number of layers to remove: Virginia building code allows a maximum of two shingle layers. Tearing off an existing layer adds $1,000-$3,000 in labor and disposal fees, including hauling to the Ivy Materials Utilization Center.
- Structural repairs needed: Rotted decking or damaged rafters found during tear-off cost $50-$100 per sheet of plywood and $200+ per rafter. Virginia's humid summers accelerate wood rot, especially on north-facing slopes.
Tips for Hiring
- Get at least 3 written estimates before deciding
- Verify licensing through Virginia DPOR (Department of Professional and Occupational Regulation)
- Ask for proof of insurance and bonding
- Check online reviews on multiple platforms
- Ask for references from recent jobs in the Lake Monticello area