
Best Handymans in Lake Monticello, VA
19 verified handymans serving Lake Monticello. Compare ratings, read reviews, and get free estimates.
Ranked Pros
19
scored & compared
Average Cost
$70–$186
per hour
Top Score
54/100
HomeProx rating
Service Area
Lake Monticello
Fluvanna County
How we rank handymans
Every business gets a HomeProx Score (0-100) based on multiple trust signals. Here is how the score breaks down:
30
Google Rating
20
Review Volume
15
VA License
15
Yelp Rating
Additional points for BBB accreditation (10), free estimates (5), and web presence (5). Rankings are updated hourly.
Hiring a handyman in Lake Monticello
We tracked 19 handymans working in Lake Monticello, VA and scored each one on the signals that actually matter when a contractor is walking into your home: Google and Yelp reviews at scale, verified Virginia DPOR licensing, BBB standing, and whether they publish pricing or offer free estimates. Typical handyman pricing in the Fluvanna County area runs $70–$186 per hour, though the ends of that range reflect very different jobs.
If you're hiring for general work in Lake Monticello, focus on three things: check the license at dpor.virginia.gov, get at least three written estimates (pricing spreads are wider than homeowners expect), and read the 1-star reviews — they tell you more about the operation than the 5-stars do. Below is the ranked list; each profile has the review themes, pricing range, and credential check for that specific business.
19 Handymans, ranked
Why #1: 4.8-star Google rating from 113 reviews. offers free estimates.
Why #2: 5.0-star Google rating from 101 reviews. offers free estimates.
Why #3: 4.9-star Google rating from 86 reviews. offers free estimates.
Why #4: 4.3-star Google rating (116 reviews). offers free estimates.
Why #5: 4.6-star Google rating from 59 reviews. offers free estimates.
Why #6: 5.0-star Google rating (33 reviews). offers free estimates.
Why #7: 5.0-star Google rating (28 reviews). offers free estimates.
Why #8: 5.0-star Google rating (17 reviews). offers free estimates.
Why #9: 4.8-star Google rating (32 reviews). offers free estimates.
Why #10: 4.9-star Google rating (27 reviews). offers free estimates.
Why #11: 4.5-star Google rating (17 reviews). offers free estimates.
Why #12: 5.0-star Google rating (6 reviews). offers free estimates.
Why #13: 5.0-star Google rating (4 reviews). offers free estimates.
Why #14: 4.5-star Google rating (8 reviews). offers free estimates.
Why #15: 5.0-star Google rating (2 reviews). offers free estimates.
Why #16: 5.0-star Google rating (1 reviews). offers free estimates.
Why #17: 5.0-star Google rating (1 reviews). offers free estimates.
Why #18: 5.0-star Google rating (1 reviews). offers free estimates.
Why #19: 1.0-star Google rating (1 reviews). offers free estimates.
Cost Guide
$70–$186
per hour
See full breakdown
Related Services
How to Hire a Handyman in Lake Monticello
Finding a reliable handyman in Lake Monticello, VA starts with understanding what drives costs and quality in the Fluvanna County area. We've compiled 19 verified professionals to help you compare.
Key Cost Factors
- Type of task: Simple tasks like hanging shelves or replacing a faucet cost $100-$200, while more involved work like installing a door or building a custom shelf unit runs $300-$600. Tasks requiring specialized skills (minor tile repair, trim carpentry) command higher rates.
- Time required: Most handymen charge by the hour ($50-$100/hr) with a 1-2 hour minimum. Bundling multiple small tasks into a single half-day visit ($300-$400) is the most cost-effective approach and is how many Charlottesville-area handymen prefer to book.
- Materials needed: Labor-only jobs like adjusting doors or tightening fixtures are cheapest. Projects requiring materials add cost, though most handymen mark up materials 10-20% for the convenience of sourcing them from local suppliers like Barracks Road Lowe's or the Charlottesville Home Depot.
- Accessibility: Ground-level work is standard rate, but tasks requiring ladders, attic crawling, or working in tight crawl spaces add time and difficulty. Two-story interior work requiring scaffolding can add $100-$200 to a job.
Tips for Hiring
- Get at least 3 written estimates before deciding
- Verify licensing through Virginia DPOR (Department of Professional and Occupational Regulation)
- Ask for proof of insurance and bonding
- Check online reviews on multiple platforms
- Ask for references from recent jobs in the Lake Monticello area